Loco Cigar Selection @ Common John July 9, 2025
Leaf by Oscar - Connecticut $11
Mellow to medium-bodied, this complex handmade gives off sweet notes of tobacco and cream, backed by a mixture of cedar and spice to keep things interesting.
Leaf by Oscar - Maduro $11
honey-like sweetness, with notes of chocolate and black pepper in the mix.
Island Jim - Connecticut $12 (by the same people as the Leaf)
It offers a medium-bodied smoke with notes of cedar, earth, sweet spice, and occasional bursts of cocoa. A fun and flavorful cigar that stands out both in appearance and taste.
Wild Hunter $12.50 (by the same people as the Leaf)
Maduro variant delivers a richer profile of leather, dark chocolate, espresso, and bold pepper, finishing medium to full in strength
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story $9.50
Handcrafted in the Dominican Republic, it features a rich Cameroon wrapper over aged Dominican binder and fillers, offering a smooth, medium-bodied profile with notes of cedar, spice, and a touch of sweetness. Its perfecto shape and expert construction make it an ideal quick smoke without sacrificing complexity or elegance.
Pappy Van Winkle $16
Blending fire‑cured Kentucky tapa negra and Mexican San Andrés wrappers over Nicaraguan binder and fillers. Barrel-aged in Pappy Van Winkle bourbon barrels, it delivers a complex, medium‑to‑full-bodied profile marked by rich oak, vanilla, spice, leather, and a subtly sweet finish.
Brickhouse Natural Robusto $8
Nicaraguan puro wrapped in a medium-brown Havana Subido leaf. It delivers a well-built, medium‑to‑full-bodied smoke with a strong foundation of earth and cedar, accented by nutty and spicy undertones, and finishes with a subtle sweet note—often described as maple‑syrup-like or creamy toast
Brickhouse Maduro Maduro Robusto $8
Medium-to-full-bodied Nicaraguan puro wrapped in an oily, Brazilian Arapiraca Maduro that delivers bold, rich flavors. Expect a peppery kick upfront, then creamy cocoa, leather, coffee, and caramel layers, with earthy and nutty mid-notes and a smooth, even burn and draw.
Joya Cabinetta $9
medium-bodied Nicaraguan puro known for its unique dual-wrapper design—an Ecuadorian Shade wrapper with a darker Nicaraguan Criollo cap. This creates a smooth, evolving flavor profile that begins with creamy wood, hay, and light spice, then transitions into richer notes of cocoa, coffee, and toasted cedar as the darker wrapper kicks in. It's well-constructed, draws easily, and offers a refined, mellow experience with just enough complexity to keep it interesting. A great choice for those who enjoy a balanced, flavorful cigar that doesn't overwhelm.
Cuatro Cinco Double Robusto $14
Box-pressed, medium-to-full-bodied cigar made to commemorate the company’s 45th anniversary. It features a rich and complex flavor profile with notes of dark chocolate, espresso, almonds, oak, and a distinctive marzipan sweetness that builds through the smoke. The blend transitions smoothly from creamy and sweet to earthy and spicy, finishing with a touch of pepper. It's known for its excellent construction and elegant balance, making it a favorite among seasoned cigar smokers.
Tabak Dulce Corona $11
A mild-to-medium, coffee-infused Nicaraguan cigar topped with a creamy Connecticut Shade wrapper. It delivers a comforting blend of espresso, milk chocolate, molasses, and velvety sweetness from start to finish, with luxurious clouds of smoke and excellent burn quality
Leather Rose Petite Corona $8
A medium‑to‑full-bodied Nicaraguan cigar wrapped in a dark Brazilian Maduro over an Indonesian binder and Nicaraguan filler. Its flavor profile is rich and sweet—initial notes of vanilla cream, cinnamon, and black cavendish–style tobacco evolve into toffee, nutmeg, leather, cedar, and a white‑pepper finish.
Leather Rose Torpedo $11.50
Sweet Jane Corona $10
A medium-bodied, candy-like Maduro from the “Yummy Bitches” lineup (rolled by Drew Estate), renowned for its sweet, dessert-like flavor. It offers upfront notes of sweet earth, cocoa, and cinnamon, supported by creamy tobacco and mocha, with an easygoing finish that builds into warm spice and delicate vanilla
Sweet Jane Tin (cigarillo) $24
Fat Bottom Betty Robusto $11
a medium-bodied Nicaraguan puro wrapped in a dark, oily Maduro that delivers a naturally sweet, dessert-style profile without being infused. From the first puff, expect rich notes of chocolate, molasses, gingerbread, and creamy eggnog, evolving into layered flavors of spice, pepper, and floral undertones as you progress
Reviewers describe it as “a heavenly dessert cigar—sweet, spiced, super smooth” with holiday‑cookie aromatics and a velvety retrohale
Acid Tin Krush Blue $24
Smooth Connecticut shade and infused with Drew Estate’s signature blend of herbs, essential oils, and aromatics. It offers a quick, flavorful smoke—roughly 15–20 minutes—featuring sweet, nutty, coffee, and brown sugar notes, with a gentle pepper finish and creamy, aromatic draw
Tatina Groovy Blue La Vita $6
A mild, flavored Dominican cigar wrapped in Indonesian leaf and infused with a playful blend of berries soaked in vanilla, honey, and cognac. It’s renowned for its smooth, mellow smoke and sweet aroma—often described as tasting like raspberry‑vanilla honey with a touch of cognac
Tatina Cherry $6
a mild-to-medium flavored cigar handcrafted in the Dominican Republic with Cuban-seed Dominican fillers and binder, all wrapped in a smooth Indonesian leaf. It delivers a pleasant burst of ripe cherry upfront, followed by creamy sweetness and a mellow tobacco base—often described as “smooth and mellow” with a lingering fruity aroma.